Gathering ideas

Christmas

Cookie exchange rules and how to host one

The simple rules of a cookie swap: how many to bake, how to avoid six plates of the same cookie, and what the host provides.

A cookie tin filled with jam thumbprints, chocolate crinkles and shortbread stars.

A cookie exchange is a party where each guest bakes one kind of cookie and goes home with some of everyone else's. It works when the host sets a few rules ahead of time.

Set the number

Decide how many cookies each person bakes and say it in the invitation. A common rule is half a dozen for each guest who comes, plus a few to taste at the party. For eight guests that is about four dozen each. If that sounds like a lot, cap the party at six people.

Stop the duplicates

Ask each guest to say what they are baking before the day. Keep the list where everyone can see it, so the second person who planned sugar cookies picks something else. Peanut butter, chocolate chip and sugar cookies go first, so claim early.

Ask about allergies

Nuts are the big one. Ask guests to bring a card with the name of the cookie and what is in it.

What the host provides

  • A long table with room for every plate
  • Boxes, tins or bags for carrying cookies home
  • Something that is not sweet: cheese, vegetables, a pot of soup
  • Coffee, tea, milk or cider
  • Paper and pens for the labels

On the day

Let people taste first. Then go around the table together, each person taking the agreed number from every plate.

ShareFacebookFollow Needbit on InstagramThe link to this page: needbit.app/blog/cookie-exchange

More gathering ideas